Kanna Hashimoto × Taishi Nakagawa BaZi Compatibility: Mutual Spouse Stars but Six Clash in Marriage Palaces, a Mid-Level Fate of "Mutual Attraction and Clash" After Years of Secret Dating

A couple rumored by Japanese media for years—Kanna Hashimoto and Taishi Nakagawa. From dating rumors after co-starring in a 2022 film, to rumors of a proposal and her acceptance, to mid-way breakup rumors, then rumors of cohabitation and imminent marriage... the buzz comes in waves. But as of now, neither has officially confirmed a relationship or marriage; all remains at the level of media reports and rumors. So purely from the BaZi structure, are these two charts compatible or not?

Let's start with the conclusion: This is a very interesting "mid-level, mutually attractive yet clashing" chart. The two are each other's spouse stars—the male's Day Master is Ren Water, whose wife star is Fire, and the female's Day Master is Bing Fire, which is precisely that Fire; the female's Day Master is Bing Fire, whose husband star is Water, and the male's Day Master is Ren Water, which is precisely that Water. This is an extremely strong signal of mutual attraction, no wonder they've been entangled for years of secret dating. But unfortunately, their marriage palaces (Day Branches) are Chen-Xu Six Clash, Day Masters Ren and Bing overcome each other, Monthly Stems Wu and Yi overcome each other, and Monthly Branches Wu and Chou harm each other—the same-frequency attraction and clashing tension are simultaneously maximized. This perfectly matches the repeated rhythm of "together then breakup, breakup then reunion" over the years.

First, Look at Their Charts

Both have only three pillars publicly known (hour pillar unknown), but the Day Master, Ten Gods, and marriage palace (Day Branch) are unaffected by the Hour Pillar, so the main axis of compatibility analysis still holds. In the tables below, the Hour Pillar is left blank.

Taishi Nakagawa (Male Chart, born 1998-06-14, Tokyo) Day Master: Ren Water.

Kanna Hashimoto (Female Chart, born 1999-02-03, Fukuoka) Day Master: Bing Fire.

Fortune Analysis: Why Are They "Constantly Entangled and Repeatedly Coming Together and Apart"?

Mutual Spouse Stars: The Source of Attraction

The strongest signal of mutual attraction in marriage compatibility is the two being each other's spouse stars—and this pair exactly fits.

• Male Taishi Nakagawa (Day Master Ren Water): For a male, the wealth star (what I overcome) is the wife star. Ren Water overcomes Fire, so his wife star is Fire. And Kanna Hashimoto's Day Master is precisely Bing Fire—to him, she is a ball of wife-star fire.
• Female Kanna Hashimoto (Day Master Bing Fire): For a female, the officer star (what overcomes me) is the husband star. Water overcomes Fire, so her husband star is Water. And Taishi Nakagawa's Day Master is precisely Ren Water—to her, he is that pool of husband-star water.

The Day Masters of the two are exactly the person the other is looking for in fate. This "mutual spouse star" structure is a rare strong magnetic field in relationships—it explains why, from their co-starring in 2022 to repeated rumors of ups and downs, they have always been entangled and rumors never stop.

Marriage Palace (Day Branch) Chen-Xu Six Clash: The Crack Within the Attraction

But in the same chart, the problem lies in the most central position—the marriage palace.

In compatibility analysis, comparing Day Branches is the main axis for seeing whether two people can settle into a life together. The calculation shows that their Day Branches Chen (Nakagawa) versus Xu (Hashimoto) are a Six Clash. Chen-Xu Clash is "two Earth repositories clashing," symbolizing turbulence, pulling, more separation than togetherness, and the relationship being easily affected by external changes (schedules, public opinion, individual career rhythms).

This is the most critical tension in this chart: at the Heavenly Stem level, they are each other's spouse stars, strongly attracted; at the Earthly Branch level, their marriage palaces clash, making it hard to settle down peacefully. The tighter the attraction, the more obvious the clash—the back-and-forth in rumors of "together → breakup → reunion → imminent marriage" makes sense from the fortune structure.

Other Pillar Positions: Overcome and Harm Stacking

Besides the marriage palace, other pillars are also tense:

• Day Masters Ren and Bing overcome each other: Water and Fire inherently overcome each other; their personality foundations are one soft and one fierce, requiring deliberate adjustment in daily life.
• Monthly Stems Wu and Yi overcome each other: The Month Pillar represents growth environment, family, and interaction patterns; this layer also carries overcoming.
• Monthly Branches Wu and Chou harm each other: Harm indicates hidden awkwardness, easy misunderstandings, and hard-to-resolve grudges.

The only obvious same-frequency point is the Year Pillar: both have the same Heavenly Stem Wu and the same Earthly Branch Yin (both born in the Tiger year). Their underlying values and birth rhythms are similar, which is the foundation for their mutual understanding and long-lasting entanglement.

Why Is the Rating "Mid-Level" Rather Than Higher?

Summing up the objective relationship: strong mutual attraction (mutual spouse stars) plus same-frequency Year Pillar are pluses, but the marriage palace Six Clash plus Day Master overcoming plus Month Pillar overcoming and harm are solid minuses. The positives and negatives offset, and the algorithm gives a mid-level rating.

Mid-level does not mean "impossible," but rather "requires effort, not innate harmony." This type of chart often has high emotional intensity and strong mutual attraction, but to reach a stable marriage, both parties need to be willing to actively compromise amid the turbulence brought by the marriage palace Six Clash and synchronize their rhythms. This matches their real-life back-and-forth over the years—enough attraction, but hard to settle down.

Hour Pillar Back-Calculation (Purely Speculative)

⚠️ The following is speculation, not fact. Formal analysis is based only on the verified three pillars. The actual birth hours of both are not public; this is just for fun, not as authoritative charts, and will never be written into any charting database.

If exact birth times were available, we could further examine the Hour Pillar (children palace, later life) and luck cycle synchronization to judge whether their key nodes align on the same timeline. But since the hours are not public, this part is left blank without arbitrary judgment—this is the bottom line of "never fabricating charts." The conclusion of this article is entirely based on the true values of Day Master, Ten Gods, and marriage palace, which are unaffected by the Hour Pillar.

Further Reading

• Chen Xiao × Chen Yanxi BaZi Compatibility: Mutual Spouse Stars and Three Harmony in Marriage Palaces, Why Did Strong Attraction Lead to Separation?
• Cary Fukunaga × Masami Nagasawa BaZi Compatibility: Year Pillar Double Combination, the Fate Binding a National Actress and a Hollywood Director
• Kazuya Kamenashi × Minami Tanaka BaZi Compatibility: Same-Year Warm Foundation, Why Did Success Depend on Effort?